It is the third plant to shut in 12 months, following the loss of the Tring and Crown Point sites.
A 30-day consultation process involving Amicus GPMS has started, with 98 jobs at risk. The closure has been blamed on the UK carton industry's weak profitability due to "overcapacity, customer and supplier power and pricing levels".
"Following the board's review of the three current operations at Gillingham, Crewkerne and Leicester, the outcome is the proposed closure of the Leicester site," said MY Cartons divisional managing director Stuart Goode. "We regret very much having to make this proposal."
He added that the move was made to reduce the short-run cost base to compete "successfully in the highly competitive supermarket own-label sector".
Staff at the Leicester plant could be offered alternative employment elsewhere in the MY Group. The site has a turnover of around 9m.
The decision follows MY Cartons' closure of its Crown Point site in Leeds with the loss of 100 jobs, and that of its smallest operation in Tring, Herts.
Story by Philip Chadwick
Have your say in the Printweek Poll
Related stories
Latest comments
"Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this Jo, and PrintWeek!
Please feel free to get in touch with the Howden Print Team to arrange your own Free of Charge Cyber Micro-Penetration Test to help..."
"I never quite understand the statements such as "achieved such a positive outcome for this well-established business".
The established business unfortunately failed and no longer exists, a..."
"Genuinely sorry to read this."
Up next...

Commitment, presence and energy will be much missed
Tributes paid to Lascelle Barrow

Around 300 roles may be affected
International Paper to close five UK packaging sites

Asset ownership delayed process
Reflections to be liquidated

'Start of a new era'