Trinity Mirror executives only realised the error after the newspaper had already gone to press at the publisher's Oldham and Watford plants, and distribution had begun.
The original story carried the front-page splash "On the loose", with a picture of the man, believed to be convicted rapist and 7m lottery winner Hoare, looking at 500,000 yachts in a seaside resort in the South West.
But it was only after almost 140,000 copies of the paper had been printed at the former Mirror Colour Print plants that the Sunday Mirror team realised that no-one could confirm the identity of the pictured man.
A second edition of the paper was rushed out, with a front-page splash about footballer Wayne Rooney taking the place of the original story.
Trinity Mirror confirmed that that 95% of the incorrect copies had been retrieved and destroyed.
But the publisher made no further comment and declined to give further details on the timing or cost of the mishap.
Story by Josh Brooks
Have your say in the Printweek Poll
Related stories
Latest comments
"And here's me thinking they bought the Docklands Light Railway."
"15 x members? Why don't they throw their lot in with the Strategic Mailing Partnership (SMP) and get a louder voice?"
"Some forty plus years ago I was at a "sales" training seminar and got chatting to the trainer after the session had finished.
In that conversation he told me about another seminar he had..."
Up next...

29% say quick turnaround work best growth area
Printers see opportunity in quick turnarounds and web-to-print

Commitment to developing talent recognised
Apprenticeship award for Coveris

2024 saw a sharp rise in response rates
JICMail data reveals growth in customer acquisition through mail campaigns

Scottish group has international ambitions